A few years ago I made a not very funny April's fool joke about trekking barefoot to save weight. Now the joke is on me since barefoot running shoes are all over the place at the moment. And if you can run in it, you can walk in it. Here is a small look at the current situation.
By Martin Nordesjö
|Terraplana Vivobarefoot EVO,|
when they were still white.
Backpacking in trail-running shoes made me wonder if support and cushioning is really vital. Seeing the hype around minimalist "barefoot" running shoes - without any cushioning or support - I was curious if there were any products suitable for lightweight backpacking.
By asking nicely we received a pair of Vivobarefoot Evo from Terraplana, one of the first designated running shoes to compete with the Vibram Fivefingers. During this summer Fjäderlätt put them to the test for both everyday and backpacking use.
This far we quite like them and will write a review later. Since they are running shoes, they are not really designed for terrain. They are not very grippy, not very durable in the upper and the colour of our pair might not be perfect for slushing through swamps...
|The EVO comes in other colors too|
What are the other alternatives until Terraplana makes a trail-running version? Not very many at the moment, but next year there will be quite a few.
Our British lightpacking favorite will launch trail-running shoes without any cushioning called Baregrip 200. The most minimalistic "shoes" yet will be the Smurfy Fivefinger challenger Evoskin - a silicone glove for your feet. One of the new Road-X models might also be a moccasin.
|Inov-8 Evoskin. Less is Smurf.|
|Inov-8 Baregrip 200|
Merrell have teamed up with Vibram to create a less Hobbit-like collection than the Fivefingers, called Merrel Barefoot. The most interesting shoes for trekking are the True Glove, Trail Glove and Pace Glove.
|Merrell Pace Glove|
|Merrell Trail Glove|
New Balance Minimus
|Merrell True Glove|
New Balance will have at least three moccasin models. The Minimus Trail looks like it could be perfect for trekking.
|New Balance Minimus range|
Last but not least Vibram Fivefingers
|Teaser of the NB Minimus Trail|
Vibram more or less stumbled into barefoot running with their now "de facto standard" Fivefingers and have expanded their range. Many models to choose from, for example KSO, Bikila, Speed and the new Trek Sport.
|Trek Sport - terrain sole and bamboo upper|
As you can see we are a quite excited about this trend. For it is a trend, complete with starry eyed evangelists and angry unenthusiasts. But the only way to find out if it is any good is to try it ourselves.
Have we missed any good ones? Please leave a comment!
GoLite's new BareTech line of shoes are somewhat barefoot. The new site should launch on the 15th but in the mean time you can see some of them on Zappos.com or various running blogs. Also, Soft Star Shoes has some barefoot running shoes. They're custom made per order and you can have them fitted for your particular feet. IMO, they're closer to barefooting than VFFs.ReplyDelete
Yes, I saw the Golites, but counted them out as too cushioned.ReplyDelete
I also left out the Feelmax shoes, since they seem to be too slippery. (?)
The Soft Star Runamoc are really close to barefoot! A bit too much moccasin for my taste, but that's just me.
Yet another alternative are ordinary Beach Shoes, in mesh or neoprene.
The Merrels don't look too bad, and the Five Fingers Trek Sport look more sturdy - but then when they become more sturdy I start to wonder if there is any benefit to having five separate toes.ReplyDelete
The problem for me with most of these is going to be the toe box. The NB, Inov8 baregrip, and likely the Merrell are all far too narrow in the toe. This is a very common problem with almost all shoes today.ReplyDelete
Great post as always.
I used a pair of Icebug Celeritas for a hike this summer. They resemble the Baregrip quite a lot - grippy sole, no cushioning and water-repellent materials.
They were great.
You could also try other classic orienteering/fell running brands like Jalas, VJ, Olway or Walsh.
Many of the their shoes are lightweight, low profile and water repellent - although not GTX - the idea is just to not absorb water and to dry out rather quickly. (Which my Icebugs did too.)
I bought my Icebugs one size up, to get enough room for warmer socks or waterproof socks.
But I also ran barefoot in them and it was comfy too.
During the hike I used thin nylon socks.
Keep on keeping on.
I totally agree about the toe box. It's about styling I guess, but you would think these products were above tha (the Fivefingers certainly are :) ).
If you can't spread your toes, and wrap your forefoot around the terrain, a large part of the freedom is lost. That is of course true for any shoe, but especially these.
The roomy toe box is part why I like my Inov-8 Terroc 330.
I've tried Inov8 295, 310, and 330. They're all too narrow for me, even if I go up a full size. Take a loot at http://www.softstarshoes.com/images/products/250V/250V_run_red_top.jpg for what a shoe *should* look like.ReplyDelete
I have tried a pair of Terraplana Vivobarefoot EVO, they look great and are wide in the toebox, but I can't use them because the heel on the shoe is too high and too stiff, so I get really bad blisters. But I was recently on a hike on Kungsleden in Sweden with a pair of Keen Venice H2, they are just great to walk with! Airy and very fast drying, not even a sign of blisters after 70 km hiking :-)ReplyDelete
Now I have ordered a pair of Soft Star Shoes RunAmoc, waiting and hoping they will pass the Swedish customs quickly :-)
The Feelmax shoes have decent grip on most surfaces but the is totally no grip on slippery mud but thats true for most shoes.ReplyDelete
The new Inov-8 Evoskins don't have likely a lonf lifespan. Another option, and even lighter could be swimming/watersports socks made of latex. With them one could wear insoles and socks depending on the need. A pair of these socks in size 45 weights 35g. Another use would be inside a wet trail runner while in camp...
As I commented on Hendriks post about the VFF shoes there are a couple of reservations I have about such minimalist footwear. While I agree with the minimal heel lift, reduced motion control and lighter weight of minimalist footwear I feel that many of these models don't provide enough 'protection' from rough, rocky trails that we encounter here in western Norway, especially on longer trips. A lot of these shoes also try to shed weight by removing material from the side of the shoe, increasing the chance of stones, sand, thorns, etc from getting inside. The Inov8 200s are probably as 'minimal' as I will go.ReplyDelete
HHMMM, the soft star shoes are beautiful and that already 25 years. But how will perform the leather upperpart in wet circumstances??It is always wet in the woods where I live so real barefoot is maybe better. An advantage with barefoot walking is that you learn to almost 'feel' where you go.You will have to, because you will surely hit something which will hurt...But you can also make yourself a real moccasin and if you want glue a thin rubber sole under it, much cheaper I guess.But what is happening at the moment is interesting, I am especially interested in the soft star runamoc, how they will perform here in the wet Sweden.ReplyDelete
It will perhaps not be the thing most of you are looking for but I love (and truly love love love) my huaraches. Huaraches are traditional running footwear from the Tarahumara Indians and it is basically nothing more than a sheet of rubber with a leather string. For (by now) habitual barefooters like me it is ideal :).ReplyDelete
Thanks a lot for sharing the info! It is valuable for me who will never think about trekking in boots... I use the vibram fivefingers at the moment, but am keen on getting a pair without the toes, because when you use them on town there's a never ending ammount of questions about them. Sometimes it makes me feel like an animal on a zoo. I would love to have one of these pair but in plain black. That's what I like about my vibrams, that they are plain black. You have any info if these models are available in black och any other dark color (preferrably without dots, lines etc..)ReplyDelete
Unfortunately most "sporty" shoes come with "sporty" styling...ReplyDelete
As far as I know the blackest of the coming shoes is one of the Merrells, not mentioned above since it's made of leather and not so fast drying. I think it's called Tough Glove (some press material swap the Tough and the True, so I'm not sure): http://www.gear.com/wp-content/images/posts/full_3229_3.jpg
New Balance Miniums Walking comes in black, I think. But with some unblack details...
The Vivobarefoot Evo comes in a black version with some red details, and the newer Evo II comes in a black with yellow details. There is also a Evo II in dark blue which looks quite nice: http://www.terraplana.com/evo-ii-p-2215.html?colour=333
Next year there is a more amphibic version of the Evo coming, called Ultra. I've only seen it in white, but maybe there will be a black too?